Reese’s has decided that a regular peanut butter cup simply isn't enough. The brand is bringing back its enormous peanut butter cup, this time as a literal pie weighing 3.25 pounds and containing approximately 7,680 calories. Forget pumpkin pie for a second. This thing is basically an entire Thanksgiving dessert table compressed into one giant chocolate shell.
The Reese’s Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie measures around nine inches across and combines the brand’s classic milk chocolate coating with a creamy peanut butter filling. It isn't a traditional pie with a crust, either. It's essentially one massive Reese’s cup designed to be sliced up and shared, assuming you can convince everyone at the table to stop staring at it first.
This isn't the first time Reese’s has attempted something this ridiculous. The original Thanksgiving Pie launched in 2021, when Hershey produced just 3,000 units priced at $44.99 each. They reportedly sold out within hours, leaving plenty of fans who missed out hoping the giant treat would eventually return.
Now, the oversized cup is making another appearance. The new 52-ounce version has shown up in online listings and has reportedly been spotted at BJ’s Wholesale Club for $39.99, although availability and pricing may vary by retailer and location. The listed calorie count works out to 48 servings of 160 calories each, according to the product's nutrition information.
With Thanksgiving approaching in the US, the timing makes sense. Reese’s has found a way to turn its most recognizable candy into a centerpiece dessert, and the sheer size alone makes it the kind of thing that could dominate someone's holiday dinner photos.
The real question is whether anyone is actually cutting this into 48 sensible servings or whether somebody is about to claim a quarter of the pie as their personal portion. Either way, Reese’s has officially entered its oversized dessert era again.